A few years ago when we first started talking about moving somewhere, we spent a lot of time thinking about where we might want to move to. While it might just seem like we moved as far away from Texas as possible on a whim, a lot of analysis went into choosing Seattle.
At the time, we knew we were bored with D/FW and wanted to live somewhere different, but we didn't really have any preconceptions about where we'd like to live. We both wanted better weather and I wanted to live somewhere I could walk, but we were pretty open to options. So, we decided to look at quite a few of our options, gathering statistics from Sperling's Best Places (bestplaces.net) on 46 different cities. This information was divided into different categories, like population, including city size, and density, race, family (married, single, divorced, etc.), economy (unemployment, job growth, taxes), housing (home cost, rent rate), crime, climate (average temperatures and precipitation), education, transportation and commuting, cost of living, religion (percentage of people in each religion), and voting (democratic, liberal, etc.).
From there, we figured out which stats were most important. Many of the stats we gathered weren't used, but all of this was done in a spreadsheet and most of these stats were weighted slightly and contributed somewhat to our final results. We determined the most important statistics to be the percentage of people commuting by mass transit, the average high temperature in July, the population density, and the temperature comfort index.
From here, since some categories, like temperature, had multiple statistics to consider, whereas we only considered one statistic in the commute mode category, each category was averaged and then weighted individually. The three most important main categories were transportation (mostly including the percentage of people using mass transit), health/climate (mostly focusing on climate), and people (including density - the higher the better - and size - the more the better).
The point of all this wasn't to have the numbers tell us which city to move to, but to guide us in identifying some potential cities that we might like. We tinkered with our weights for each category a few times, but one of our top eleven lists included:
- San Francisco
- Washington DC
- Boston
- New York
- Philadelphia
- Chicago
- Seattle
- Newark
- Pittsburgh
- Oakland
- Portland
For what it's worth, Dallas appeared 20th in our list and Fort Worth appeared 44th.
It's kind of interesting that Seattle was 7th on our list but we moved there anyway. However, we looked at each city individually to see if there was anything that might be significant enough to rule it out. For example, while San Francisco rated very well in transportation, climate, and city size/density, its high cost of living and secular culture (while not weighted heavily by us) were undesirable enough to make us want to look down the list. Boston might have been nice, too, but the cold winters ruled it out.
All of these other highly-ranked cities had significant flaws. We looked at the lowest-rated categories of each city, and it turned out that Seattle was rated well in every category. Whereas San Francisco's cost of living earned a 25% in our arcane rating system and Pittsburgh's economy/crime earned a 16%, for example, the lowest rated thing in Seattle was 52%, which was for the cost of living. So, there wasn't really anything to push us away from Seattle. It's size and density weren't as high as I would've liked and the percentage of people using public transportation was second lowest in our top 10, but our statistics combined with the details we'd read about online, including the many things to do outdoors and the scenery made Seattle sound like a good fit. When we visited in Seattle, we both liked it in a way that we hadn't liked any other city. Since Portland also appeared somewhat high on our list (it was hurt mostly by its small size), we visited there too, since it was near Seattle, and really liked it as well. After this, we had made up our minds to move to one or the other.
While there may have been some flaws in our analysis, we think looking at the details first really helped us to find a livable home city that we really enjoy. So far what our research told us has been true, and thinking about the other options that appeared, I don't think there's anywhere I'd rather be right now.